Science, Art and Religion

Register      Login

VOLUME 1 , ISSUE 2-4 ( April-December, 2022 ) > List of Articles

REVIEW ARTICLE

Inclusivism and Tolerance

Ivan Andrijanić

Keywords : Exclusivism, Hinduism, Inclusivism, Intolerance, Tolerance

Citation Information : Andrijanić I. Inclusivism and Tolerance. 2022; 1 (2-4):180-185.

DOI: 10.5005/jp-journals-11005-0034

License: CC BY-NC 4.0

Published Online: 20-03-2023

Copyright Statement:  Copyright © 2022; The Author(s).


Abstract

In this paper, Paul Hacker's idea of inclusivism and its distinction from tolerance will be problematized; but not before the very notion and idea of tolerance are discussed, that might actually be conditioned by modern worldview and experience. Paul Hacker argues that Hinduism is not tolerant but an inclusivist religion and that a tolerant religion can only be one where a clear difference between ”itself” and ”other” is established. The article will present examples of Bhagavadgītā, which corresponds to Hacker's notion of inclusiveness, and the example of Dārā Šukūh, which corresponds to the concept of tolerance. However, while tolerance is a concept developed in the Western cultural and religious milieu, in Hinduism, there are many examples of inclusivism without the hierarchization of included concepts. That is why this paper would propose to postulate two types of inclusivism, one with hierarchy and the other without. An example of inclusivism without hierarchization might be Ramakrishna. The conclusion is that the situation is complex and that both types of inclusivism, the one with hierarchization and the one without, have the potential to regulate the daily practice of toleration in society.


HTML PDF Share
  1. Halbfass, Wilhelm. India and Europe: An Essay in Philosophical Understanding. Motilal Banarsidass, Delhi, 1990. [First edition in German, Schwabe & Co. AG, Basel, 1981)
  2. Ježić, Mislav. The first yoga layer in Bhagavadgītā. In: Sinha, J.P. (ed.) Ludwik Sternbach Felicitation Volume, I:545–557. Akhila Bharatiya Sanskrit Parishad, Lucknow, 1979.
  3. Ježić, Mislav. Textual Layers of the Bhagavadgītā as Traces of Indian Cultural History. In: Morgenroth, W. (ed.) Sanskrit and World Culture: Proceedings of the Fourth World Sanskrit Conference of the International Association of Sanskrit Studies, Weimar, May 23–30, 1979:628–638., Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter, 1986. DOI: 10.1515/9783112320945-101
  4. Ježić, Mislav. The Triṣṭubh Hymn in the Bhagavadgītā. In: Koskikallio, Petteri (ed.), Parallels and Comparisons. Proceedings of the Fourth Dubrovnik International Conference on the Sanskrit Epics and Purāṇas 2009;31–66. Zagreb: Croatian Academy of Sciences and Arts.
  5. Ježić, Mislav: 2021. Povijesni slojevi teksta Bhagavadgīte – predaja teksta, proširenja i preoblike pouke. Što je zajedničko Bhagavadgīti i katedrali sv. Duje? Filozofska istraživanja 2021;41(2):247–272.
  6. Hacker P. Religiöse toleranz und intoleranz in Hinduismus. Saeculum 1957;8(JG):167–179. DOI: 10.7788/saeculum.1957.8.jg.167
  7. Bakker H. Royal patronage and religious tolerance: the formative period of Gupta–Vākātaka culture. J R Asiat Soc 2010;20(4):461–475. DOI: 10.1017/S1356186310000301
  8. Hacker P. Zur Geschichte und Beurteilung des Hinduismus. Orientalische Literaturzeitung 1964;59(5–6):231–245. DOI: 10.1524/olzg.1964.59.16.116
  9. Hacker, P. Aspects of Neo-Hinduism as Contrasted with Surviving Traditional Hinduism. (Vortragsmanuskript, diskutiert am 5.5.1970 an der Universität London.). In: Schmithausen, Lambert (ed.) Paul Hacker: Kleine Schriften: 580–608, Glasenapp-Stiftung, Band 15, Franz Steiner Verlag Gmbh, Wiesbaden, 1978.
  10. Hacker, Paul. Inklusivismus. In: Oberhammer, G. (ed.): Inklusivismus. Eine indische Denkform: 11–28. Publications of the De Nobili Research Library, Occasional Papers 2, Wien 1983.
  11. Kiblinger, Kristin Beise. Buddhist Inclusivism: Attitudes Towards Religious Others. Routledge, London and New York, 2005.
  12. Törzsök, Judith. Icons of Inclusivism. In: G. Bühnemann et al. (eds.), Maṇḍalas and Yantras in the Hindu Traditions: 179–224. Brill, Leiden, 2003.
  13. Bisschop, Peter C. Inclusivism Revisited. The Worship of Other Gods in the Śivadharmaśāstra, the Skandapurāṇa and the Niśvāsamukha. In: Mirnig, Nina; Rastelli, Marion & Eltschinger, Vincent (eds.): Tantric Communities in Context: 511–537. Österreichische Akademie für Wissenschaften, Vienna, 2019.
  14. Jones, William. On The Gods Of Greece, Italy, And India. In: the works of Sir William Jones in Six Volumes, vol. 1:319–397. London, 1799.
  15. Hayat, Perwaiz. The conversation between Dārā Shukōh and Lāl Dās: a Sūfī-Yogī dialogue of the 17th - century Indian subcontinent. A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies and Research in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Institute of Islamic. Studies, McGill University, Montreal, 2006.
  16. Zagorin, Perez. How the Idea of Religious Toleration Came to the West. Princeton University Press, Princeton and Oxford, 2003.
  17. Glaser, Eliane (ed.): Religious Tolerance in the Atlantic World: Early Modern and Contemporary Perspectives. Palgrave Macmillan, 2014.
  18. Habermas J. Religious tolerance—the pacemaker for cultural rights. Philosophy 2004;79(307):5–18. DOI: 10.1017/S0031819104000026
PDF Share
PDF Share

© Jaypee Brothers Medical Publishers (P) LTD.